As Donald noted re the Goomba, I caught the end of the falling tide on the north side of the island. Caught 3 dink trout, one dink flounder, and a slot red in about 30 minutes. Once the tide movement stopped, fish activity died. About that time, late arrivals started to get their lines wet, and apparently didn't fare as well.
Amia calva - The hardest fighting fresh water fish in North America!